#30 Ups... my fault, det havde jeg ikke bemærket. Så kan det faktisk godt være, at disse også har problemmet.
An anden ting, ikke til billede men til lyden. Episode IV er ikke flagged til at køre EX i region 2 boksen. Har talt med Hannes fra Schweiz, han fortalte at den engelske lydspor på den tyske version heller ikke var EX flagged, men det tyske var!!! Både Episode V og VI er EX flagged i den danske boks. Alle tre episoder er EX flagged i region 1 boksen.
Men du har højst sandsynlig ret angående billedet på de R2 UK og R4 (Australien)... de har med stor sandsynlighed samme fejl som den danske / nordiske udgivelse....
En lille note om Hannes. Han er en hjemmeside (på tysk) www.dvdsurround.ch på den side står alle de film, der er udgivet med DTS-ES og DD-EX i hele verden. Der står også om DTS-lyden er diskret eller matrix. Men det var et sidespor.
Forskellen på dd5.1 og dd5.1-EX er vel minimal, 'EX'-delen er jo blot et separat lydspor, udelukkende bestående af lyd fra de to bagkanaler, akkurat som hvis ens 6.1 receiver selv laver en center bagkanal bestående af de to bagkanaler på et alm dd5.1 lydspor.
I modsætning til dts-ES discrete, hvor der er mixet et spor specifikt til baghøjtaleren.
Er det ikke forstået korrekt?
"I wonder if a little rum could get this back on its feet."
Men den ekstra bagkanal kan være med til at give et noget mere flydende lydbillede. Den kan også give en mere præcis placering af effekter i lydrummet. Så selvom det er lyd fra de to andre bagkanaler, har den stor betydning.
Bestemt, men 6.1 receivere kan jo selv finde ud af at kreere en center bagkanal, det ved jeg da fra alle mine 5.1 film, der kommer også lyd ud af bag-centeren selvom filmen ikke er med EX lydspor.
Om det så er bedre at det er kodet ind i lydsporet eller når forstærkeren sætter det på, skal jeg ikke kunne sige.
"I wonder if a little rum could get this back on its feet."
Her er et uddrag af et review af Ep IV fra den australske boks (der skulle være identisk med den danske), jeg har pastet den del der drejer sig om billedet:
Video: This DVD is presented in an aspect ratio of 2.35:1, and is 16x9 enhanced. That's the original and expected aspect ratio.
This disc is not a Superbit disc (not surprising, because this disc comes from Fox), but it is close. The only extra on this disc is the commentary (well, plus links to a web site).
The picture varies, but it is generally fairly sharp; a few of the scenes on Tatooine are softened by apparent heat haze, and a few of the composite scenes (particularly the land speeder scenes) are a little bit soft (probably to hide some of the composition). The picture could be sharper, but I like it — this looks clear, but a multitude of evils are covered by the very slight softening. Shadow detail is quite decent, although a bit limited in some of the darker scenes. There is no visible film grain. There's no low level noise.
Colour in some scenes is affected by coloured lighting (understandable when you have one white and one red moon). Apart from the coloured lighting, the colour is rendered well — skin tones look accurate and credible. The only thing that looks like a colour-related artefact is some strangeness about the blue colour of R2-D2 immediately after they leave the escape pod. There is no colour-bleed, and no false colouration. Blacks are black. Whites are white. Good stuff.
There are no film artefacts. None. When they restored this, they did an astonishing job of cleaning up the film.
There is some aliasing (yes, the transfer is not perfect), but it is rare, and never too disruptive. Perhaps the most obvious moment of aliasing is at 53:19, on the vent. There is one moment of faint moiré at 35:54, but you have to be really picky to notice it. There are no MPEG artefacts.
There are subtitles in five languages, including English for the Hearing Impaired, plus English subtitles for the commentary. There's a default subtitle track, too, which subtitles alien languages if you are not running any of the other subtitles. There are actually two subtitle tracks for the commentary — one just indicates who is talking, while the other is real subtitles for the commentary. I watched all of the English dialogue subtitles, and most of the commentary subtitles. The dialogue subtitles are astonishingly accurate. I managed to pick up a single error in the subtitles (at 68:55) where the subtitles say "well" instead of "wealth" (Note: not everyone agrees that this is an error — I may be worng!). As far as I can judge, every other word of dialogue has been captured in the subtitles — awesome! The subtitles are well-timed, and easy to read.
The disc is single sided, dual layered, formatted RSDL. The layer change is at 60:36, placed between two scenes, but it's fairly noticeable due to the pause.
Sharpness: 4,5 / 5 Shadow Detail: 4 / 5 Colour: 4,5 / 5 Grain/Pixelization (som er et af kritikpunkterne på jims sammenligning): 5 / 5 Film-To-Video Artefacts: 4,5 / 5 Film Artefacts: 5 / 5 Overall: 4,5 / 5
#31 Zelle 21 år siden
#32 El vez 21 år siden
Er der nogle der har lavet sammenligner specifikt med R2 UK?
Udover at sammenligne de to regioner, er der en nem måde at se om ens udgave er fejlbehæftet?
#33 maniac 21 år siden
Ikke at jeg kan li at være sortseer her...
#34 jjj 21 år siden
An anden ting, ikke til billede men til lyden. Episode IV er ikke flagged til at køre EX i region 2 boksen. Har talt med Hannes fra Schweiz, han fortalte at den engelske lydspor på den tyske version heller ikke var EX flagged, men det tyske var!!!
Både Episode V og VI er EX flagged i den danske boks. Alle tre episoder er EX flagged i region 1 boksen.
Men du har højst sandsynlig ret angående billedet på de R2 UK og R4 (Australien)... de har med stor sandsynlighed samme fejl som den danske / nordiske udgivelse....
En lille note om Hannes. Han er en hjemmeside (på tysk) www.dvdsurround.ch på den side står alle de film, der er udgivet med DTS-ES og DD-EX i hele verden. Der står også om DTS-lyden er diskret eller matrix. Men det var et sidespor.
#35 El vez 21 år siden
I modsætning til dts-ES discrete, hvor der er mixet et spor specifikt til baghøjtaleren.
Er det ikke forstået korrekt?
#36 jjj 21 år siden
Men den ekstra bagkanal kan være med til at give et noget mere flydende lydbillede. Den kan også give en mere præcis placering af effekter i lydrummet. Så selvom det er lyd fra de to andre bagkanaler, har den stor betydning.
#37 El vez 21 år siden
Om det så er bedre at det er kodet ind i lydsporet eller når forstærkeren sætter det på, skal jeg ikke kunne sige.
#38 El vez 21 år siden
Video:
This DVD is presented in an aspect ratio of 2.35:1, and is 16x9 enhanced. That's the original and expected aspect ratio.
This disc is not a Superbit disc (not surprising, because this disc comes from Fox), but it is close. The only extra on this disc is the commentary (well, plus links to a web site).
The picture varies, but it is generally fairly sharp; a few of the scenes on Tatooine are softened by apparent heat haze, and a few of the composite scenes (particularly the land speeder scenes) are a little bit soft (probably to hide some of the composition). The picture could be sharper, but I like it — this looks clear, but a multitude of evils are covered by the very slight softening. Shadow detail is quite decent, although a bit limited in some of the darker scenes. There is no visible film grain. There's no low level noise.
Colour in some scenes is affected by coloured lighting (understandable when you have one white and one red moon). Apart from the coloured lighting, the colour is rendered well — skin tones look accurate and credible. The only thing that looks like a colour-related artefact is some strangeness about the blue colour of R2-D2 immediately after they leave the escape pod. There is no colour-bleed, and no false colouration. Blacks are black. Whites are white. Good stuff.
There are no film artefacts. None. When they restored this, they did an astonishing job of cleaning up the film.
There is some aliasing (yes, the transfer is not perfect), but it is rare, and never too disruptive. Perhaps the most obvious moment of aliasing is at 53:19, on the vent. There is one moment of faint moiré at 35:54, but you have to be really picky to notice it. There are no MPEG artefacts.
There are subtitles in five languages, including English for the Hearing Impaired, plus English subtitles for the commentary. There's a default subtitle track, too, which subtitles alien languages if you are not running any of the other subtitles. There are actually two subtitle tracks for the commentary — one just indicates who is talking, while the other is real subtitles for the commentary. I watched all of the English dialogue subtitles, and most of the commentary subtitles. The dialogue subtitles are astonishingly accurate. I managed to pick up a single error in the subtitles (at 68:55) where the subtitles say "well" instead of "wealth" (Note: not everyone agrees that this is an error — I may be worng!). As far as I can judge, every other word of dialogue has been captured in the subtitles — awesome! The subtitles are well-timed, and easy to read.
The disc is single sided, dual layered, formatted RSDL. The layer change is at 60:36, placed between two scenes, but it's fairly noticeable due to the pause.
Sharpness: 4,5 / 5
Shadow Detail: 4 / 5
Colour: 4,5 / 5
Grain/Pixelization (som er et af kritikpunkterne på jims sammenligning): 5 / 5
Film-To-Video Artefacts: 4,5 / 5
Film Artefacts: 5 / 5
Overall: 4,5 / 5
Hele reviewet af Ep IV
Review af Ep V
Review af Ep VI
#39 Kalle Ferm 21 år siden
#40 El vez 21 år siden